|

Beyond the Boom: Brewing Success in a Changing Craft Beer Market

Craft Beer’s Golden Era Is Over—Now What?

“In a mature market, not every year is going to be defined by substantial growth,” BA staff economist Matt Gacioch said in a press release. “While progress may not come in additional production volume, it can still come in honing operations, business practices, and world-class beer.”

—“Annual Craft Brewing Industry Production Report and Top 50 Producing Craft Brewing Companies,” Brewers Association Reports 2024 U.S. Craft Brewing Industry Figures, April 15, 2025
Neon craft beer sign above beer taps in a bar. In the background is a menu with Chinese writing.
Photo by JF via Unsplash

Craft beer was hot for a long time. For years, all a founder needed was to open a taproom in a decent location—or even one that wasn’t ideal like an industrial park. Breweries were practically cash machines for their owners. And yet many brewery websites offered nothing more than a name, a contact page, and maybe a list of beers. There was no ethos, no character, no mission: just the bare minimum. Sometimes you’d find a story, but too often it was the same story: “I opened a brewery because I love beer.”

Don’t get me wrong—I’m not bashing these businesses. I’m simply highlighting that the requirements for success in the craft beer industry in 2025 are higher than they were before. Those days are gone. Recently Reuters served up a telling headline: “Brewers’ volumes disappoint as drinkers buy less beer.” Microbreweries (breweries that produce <15,000 barrels per year) were hit particularly hard in 2024, witnessing a 7.4% decline in volume produced. Similarly, a recent survey by Bump Williams Consulting showed that 23.3% of consumers “have stopped drinking, or are taking a break from [beverage alcohol]”.

Why Consumers Are Drinking Less—and Why It Matters

The alcohol industry as a whole is facing some key challenges:

  • Young people reaching legal drinking age are saying, “You know what? I’d rather not drink.” There are a few common reasons cited that include “a lack of interest”, “not wanting to get drunk”, and “needing the money for other things”. They also associated alcohol with “vulnerability”, “anxiety”, and “abuse”.
  • Not-so-young people are opting to drink less—or not at all. Many of them cite the negative effects of alcohol for this decision. The r/NABEER subreddit is enlightening.
  • Science is telling us that alcohol is not good for our physical health.
  • Market cycles are at work and craft beer is in a downswing.
  • And, specifically in the realm of craft, there are a ton of breweries and simultaneously there’s a noticeable decline in interest in craft beer.

Broadly, the Bump Williams Consulting survey found a number of key reasons consumers are opting to drink less alcohol. Health was the leading reason, but there were a number of other responses of note cited in the survey:

  • “Alcohol doesn’t appeal to my goals or life;”
  • “It’s bad for you and I have seen firsthand what it does to people;”
  • “To see if I really need alcohol to have ‘a good time’ or ‘loosen up’ before social events;”
  • “I don’t find the fascination or interest as much as I used to enjoy;”
  • And “don’t like the feeling of being [too] intoxicated to take care of myself [or] drive myself home.”

More Breweries, More Competition, Tighter Margins

The surge in breweries in recent years means that city dwellers no longer need to drive 30-45 minutes out to an industrial zone for craft beer. These days, there are so many breweries that consumers can stay local or easily take public transportation. With so many breweries, being “local” isn’t a unique selling point anymore. 

Many breweries are feeling squeezed by rents that have ballooned due to inflation and falling sales due to the trends highlighted above. Adding fuel to the fire, tariffs—and even the looming threat of them—alongside general inflation, are compounding challenges faced by many breweries.

Moreover, the surge in inflation over recent years has led to a dip in consumer spending. And with markets in a state of flux, coupled with uncertainties surrounding international trade, consumers will likely become even more price aware. Put differently, breweries and consumer packaged goods companies must ensure their value propositions are compelling. Within craft beer, this typically means delivering high-quality products paired with messaging that resonates emotionally with consumers. 

Finally, jumping to the notion of market cycles in beer, Bart Watson, the Brewers Association’s CEO (and formerly the organization’s chief economist), has said “if you’re just trying to ride out the short term headwinds and make it to this long-term picture, you should probably reconsider that strategy. This portion of the cycle may take years to play out. If your plan is to simply wait it out without addressing your products or marketing, you’re in for a rough ride.” 

A selection of craft beers on shelves. There is a variety of American, British, and Belgian styles along with signs that say "Porter" and "Stout".
Photo by Christin Hume via Unspslash

Growth Isn’t Dead—It Just Looks Different Now

But this isn’t a doomsday scenario! There is still plenty of potential and room for growth in the craft beer industry—an IWSR report found that, despite overall beer volumes declining in 2024, the Super Premium beer category grew by 2% in the United States in that year (“Super Premium” is a price designation, not an indication of quality). lso consider that the majority of craft-beer consumers are white and male. Last I checked, there are plenty of non-white men out there who are potential customers! Even if we’re past the peak, new opportunities are emerging—though we are now beyond the old “if you build it, they will come” mindset.

Instead of panicking, business owners need to return to fundamentals and rethink their approach to product quality as well as how they connect with customers. Now’s the time to take a hard look at your production processes and ask, “Are we continually striving to improve?” Additionally, to navigate the current state of the market, companies in the alcoholic beverage space should work to rebuild and strengthen their emotional ties with customers and guests. It’s not too late to start fostering those connections!

Remember customer retention is far more cost-effective than a constant cycle of acquiring new ones. Product improvements and marketing efforts cost money but, if done well, they pay for themselves.

Solving Today’s Problems: Quality and Connection

In the days of yore, many brewery founders could skate by with beer that was decent—or, occasionally, not even that—and a catchy name or logo. Meanwhile, I often heard a familiar lament from brewery operators: they grumbled about how consumers would frequently flock to the newest and shiniest brewery in town. Often, these trends were intertwined: without exceptional products or fostering a deeper connection with consumers beyond just offering beer they enjoyed, customers became, well, promiscuous with other brands.

The silver lining is that there are solutions to these challenges: the path from “good” to “great” products often involves a series of minor adjustments. Here’s a secret to crafting outstanding beer and to improving beer quality: while individual choices might seem insignificant, collectively they can elevate or undermine your quality.

Likewise, breweries can strive to forge emotional connections with their patrons. Heritage bourbon and American whiskey brands have mastered this approach while simultaneously ensuring their products remain top notch.

Building that emotional connection isn’t a swift or simple task. It also requires investment (marketing specialists often suggest allocating 5 – 15% of revenues). Yet, when executed well, these efforts pay dividends in the long run. 

Neon sign that says "Cold Beer, Warm Heart".
Photo by Call Me Fred via Unsplash

In my view, there’s certainly some easy wins to be had. Start by blending warm, welcoming service with knowledgeable staff who can both educate and engage guests. Toss in memorable beers to that mix and you will have a powerful combination that leaves patrons not just happy with their visit and empowered by what they’ve learned. Those feelings, in turn, will generate positive brand associations for your guests and boost their desire to visit and explore your products once again.

Additionally, take time to review your website. It might need updates in terms of language, fixing broken links, refreshed information, improved layout, or better overall performance.1 Don’t forget to audit the mobile version—a growing number of people access websites primarily through their phones.

If you don’t already have a blog, consider adding one. A blog helps engage your audience, keeps them updated on your brewery’s activities, and can significantly boost your search engine visibility. By strategically incorporating keywords, you improve your chances of ranking higher in search results. For context, websites in the first organic position (below ads) average a 39.8% click-through-rate, while second and third drop to 18.7%, and 10.2% respectively. So if someone searches for “local brewery”, being near the top of the list dramatically increases the likelihood they’ll visit your site.

Remember, your website isn’t just informational—it’s a reflection of your brand and a powerful marketing tool.

As for brewing better beer, this task is arguably more straightforward, and there are clear steps you can take:

  • Audit your processes. The key areas to look for will either improve efficiency (without negatively impacting flavor), reduce costs (also without negatively impacting flavor), or will improve overall quality. Example: adjusting the crush of your grains can lead to improved extract, improved run off from the lauter tun, or both.
  • Re-assess your recipes. The difference between a good beer and a great beer is a series of small tweaks, and so you should consider whether changes to individual malts or the ratio of malts could give your beer a boost. The key here, though, is that you don’t want to fully overhaul your recipe since customers have come to expect and love a certain flavor profile. Your goal is to embrace and refine that existing profile, while simply aiming to elevate it. For some examples on how you can re-assess your recipes, check out our recipe formulation guide!
  • Don’t overlook your water profile. Changes here can make a beer shine. Example: one of the keys to New England IPAs is a sulfate-to-chloride ratio of 1:3 or 2:3. Similarly, finding the right chloride level can help a milk stout.
  • Validate your equipment and ensure that it is reliable. Are all your readings accurate? Are you sure? Inaccurate equipment can lead to inconsistencies that negatively impact product quality. Example: your pH meter hasn’t been calibrated in a while and, over time, the pH of your beers has changed.

Some of these components might seem daunting but I assure you they are not! Even so, don’t be afraid to get outside help. 

Brewery in an industrial old brick building with light streaming in through the windows onto shiny brewery equipment.
Photo by Keith Tanner via Unsplash

Optimism in a Difficult Market

Let’s wrap things up on a hopeful note. The situation might look bleak now, but there are reasons for optimism. Re-investing in your products and branding can make a significant impact. Sadly, some businesses will have to close, and my heart truly goes out to those owners; I can only imagine what they’re experiencing and the emotional rollercoasters they must be on. 

While painful, these closures can also open doors to new opportunities: affordable equipment might become available, and new consumers will be searching for new watering holes. Be prepared for that moment when they step through your door. When newcomers arrive, you need to have everything in place that tells them “We are happy you’re here: this is your spot.” Stellar products and an incredible atmosphere will go a long way in making that happen.

Key Points

  • Breweries can no longer rely on just decent beer and a catchy logo—success today requires strategic quality and marketing.
  • The craft beer boom has slowed, but opportunity remains in premium quality, emotional storytelling, and process refinement. 
  • Today’s consumers are drinking less—but they’re also demanding more from the brands they do support.
  • Improving product quality means dialing in small, incremental changes—not necessarily a total overhaul.
  • Crafting meaningful customer experiences and connecting with consumers is also important. 

  1. Performance can lead to a lower “bounce rate”. The bounce rate of a site is the percentage of visits that result in a visitor giving up on a website before it has finished loading. If your business generates a meaningful amount of revenue via online sales, then bounce rate is particularly important: an increase in load time from 1 second to 3 seconds leads to a 32% bounce rate, and when it increases to 10 seconds, the bounce rate shoots up to 123%. Also: “Study: Retailers leaving ‘billions’ on table due to poor website performance” ↩︎

Similar Posts