Crystal Malt vs Caramel Malt: A Small but Meaningful Distinction

Are Crystal Malt and Caramel Malt the Same Thing?
Beer professionals often use the terms “crystal malt” and “caramel malt” as if they’re the same. Here’s the thing: although the two can be very similar, they’re not always the same. Understanding the differences is key to consistently brewing great beer. The distinction matters when you’re trying to ensure a recipe delivers exactly what you intend.
The Place to Start: How Malting Actually Works

Let’s start with the basics of malting to understand what makes crystal and caramel malts different.
Maltsters trigger germination (i.e., the barley gets tricked into growing) through cycles of soaking in water and resting in air. In response, the barley releases enzymes that break down its interior cellulose matrix, making the carbohydrates inside the kernel more accessible to brewers.
After this stage, the barley has a moisture content of 45–47% and is called “green malt.” It could technically be used for brewing (and some people do1), but its high moisture content makes it unstable and impractical. So it’s dried — either in a kiln or a drum roaster.

Base malt is typically dried in a kiln, whereas black malt is dried in a drum roaster—only drum roasters can provide the heat that is necessary to produce black malt.
So why does the drying method matter? Isn’t heat just heat?
Well, black malt holds a clue. While specialty kilns only get up to 250–255°F (121–124°C), drum roasters “are capable of surpassing the point of spontaneous combustion—about 450°F (238°C)”.2 These temperature differences are key when it comes to producing caramel malt or a “true” crystal malt.
Faster, Pussycat! Kiln! Kiln! (Where Crystal and Caramel Diverge)
What Actually Makes a “True” Crystal Malt?
Let’s take a look at what makes a true crystal malt first. In Malt, John Mallett clarifies the confusion that “Although crystal and caramel are used interchangeably when describing this type of malt, there are some notable differences. The glassy, crystallized interior characteristic of ‘true’ crystal malts requires the use of a drum roaster.”3
Greg Noonan provides some additional distinctions in New Brewing Lager Beer:
“True crystal malts are completely saccharified in a moisture-saturated environment at 158°F (70°C) for 1.5 to 2 hours. The stewing of the malt liquefies and completely saccharifies it before it is brought up to kilning-off temperatures. Crystal malts are drum kilned at 250 to 275°F (120 to 135°C) for 1.5 to 2 hours, depending on the color desired. They give flavors that are crisper and cleaner than caramel malts; the lighter-colored crystal malts especially give less bitterness and pungency than caramel malts.”4
Together we have some helpful information on true crystal malts:
- Require a drum roaster capable of higher temperatures;
- Are fully saccharified before final kilning;
- Develop a vitrified (glassy) interior;
- Undergo longer high-temperature drying (typically 1.5–2 hours).
In short, true crystal malts undergo complete internal conversion before being exposed to high finishing temperatures. That combination produces their distinctive glassy interior and characteristic flavor profile.
What Defines a “True” Caramel Malt?
With crystal malt out of the way, we can take a look at caramel malts. Noonan comes to the rescue again:
“Caramel malts have a higher moisture content, are not completely saccharified [n.b., this means that the starches have not fully been converted into sugars], and are not kilned to the point that the endosperm is entirely vitrified/glassy. Both [caramel and crystal malts] are commonly kilned in drums. Both are surface dried at temperatures rising to 150°F (65°C) over an hour’s time, during which period a significant amount of proteolysis occurs.”5
According to an article by Terry Foster and Bob Hansen, caramel malts can be produced in either a kiln or a drum, but they also clarify that “the term crystal malt is normally reserved for caramel malts produced in a roaster.” So, in reality “true” caramel malts are not produced in a drum roaster.
Noonan goes on to provide some additional context for caramel malts:
“‘Caramel’ versions of CaraPils (CaramelPils, CaraPilsen) malt are generally raised to 212°F (100°C) within five to ten minutes, then held there for thirty to forty-five minutes without ventilation to ‘caramelize’ the endosperm. After kilning, the temperature is reduced to 175°F (80°C) to cure for forty-five minutes…”6
We now have some key information about true caramel malts:
- Produced in a kiln;
- Retain higher moisture content;
- Are not fully saccharified;
- Do not develop a fully vitrified interior;
- Typically undergo shorter high-temperature exposure.
In contrast to true crystal malts, true caramel malts do not complete saccharification before final drying. That difference affects both mash behavior and sensory contribution.
It’s worth noting that Noonan mentions that crystal malts are often kiln dried, but Mallett very clearly states that drum roasters are essential. Given that New Brewing Lager Beer was published in 1996 and Malt in 2014, it’s reasonable to assume that both equipment and terminology evolved during that period.

Crystal Malt vs Caramel Malt: The Real Differences at a Glance
At its core, the distinction comes down to three variables: moisture content, degree of saccharification, and the intensity and duration of heat application. Those process differences determine whether a malt develops a fully vitrified interior—and how it will behave in the mash.
Because true crystal malts are fully saccharified before drying, they contribute pre-formed sugars directly to the mash. True caramel malts may contain residual starch, meaning their behavior can vary slightly depending on mash conditions.
Let’s break down into a simple table to make it easier to understand. One quick clarification: because “caramel malt” is sometimes used as a broad umbrella term, I’ve separated the categories below into:
- “True caramel malts” (malts that are not fully saccharified and do not meet crystal malt criteria)
- “True crystal malts” (fully saccharified malts with a vitrified interior).
The confusion isn’t about whether these malts are similar—it’s about how and when they’re produced.
|
True Caramel Malts |
True Crystal Malts |
|---|---|
|
Higher moisture content |
Lower moisture content |
|
Not fully saccharified |
Fully saccharified |
|
Produced in a kiln |
Produced in a drum roaster |
|
Shorter processing time |
Longer processing time |
|
Some true crystal malts are referred to as “caramel malts” |
How We Got Ourselves Confused
So why all this confusion? In that same article, Terry Foster and Bob Hansen explain that UK-based maltsters began exporting their crystal malts to the US. At that time, American homebrewers were using similar malts that were called “caramel malts”. Those brewers assumed their caramel malts were different from the imports from the UK. Although this was true in some instances, it was (and still is) mostly true that some malts labelled “caramel malt” are, in fact, crystal malts.
Ultimately, Foster and Hansen echo Mallett: “with certain exceptions caramel malts are crystal malts, and the terms are often used interchangeably in the malting trade.”
They add one interesting piece of history: the original crystal malts were made using a drum roaster. (Interested in a little more history? Click the footnote at the end of this sentence!7).
So… Does This Actually Matter?
Wait, why does any of this matter when crystal malts and caramel malts are so similar?!
Here’s the thing: making great beer is a series of deliberate choices. Knowledge informs those choices. Understanding the difference between crystal and caramel malts helps you make smarter decisions, particular with recipe development.
There are also process-related reasons that tie in to product consistency. The moisture content and saccharification levels of each type of malt matter.
Substituting Crystal for Caramel (or Vice Versa): What to Watch For
Will this distinction make or break a beer on its own? Probably not.
In many recipes, substituting one for the other won’t cause disaster—but it may subtly affect sweetness, body, and mash performance. When you’re scaling recipes or building a flagship beer, those subtle differences compound over time.
The big picture: brewing with intention
But great beer isn’t built on one big decision—it’s built on dozens of small, deliberate ones. Moisture content, saccharification level, and processing method all influence how a malt behaves in the mash—and ultimately, how it shapes the finished beer.
If you care about repeatability, hitting your specifications, and developing recipes with intention rather than assumption, this distinction matters.
- Some distilleries use “green malt”. This is malt that is fresh from steeping and hasn’t undergone any drying. They have to use the malt incredibly quickly. ↩︎
- Malt by John Mallett, page 77 ↩︎
- Malt by John Mallett, page 77 ↩︎
- New Brewing Lager Beer by Greg Noonan, page 120 ↩︎
- New Brewing Lager Beer by Greg Noonan, page 119 ↩︎
- New Brewing Lager Beer by Greg Noonan, page 119 ↩︎
- In the 19th century, porter was brewed with roasted malts, just as it is today. Back then, porter started to fall out of favor. At the same time, original gravities were declining. As OGs declined, beers became less flavorful. The authors think that at some point a maltster had the brilliant idea to create a malt that could add flavor to these beers and crystal malts were born. ↩︎


